Skip the greetings.
Negative review of Kara Sevda
1. The cultural shock
Basically, I know that Turki had change from the traditional Islam country to a ... emm how I can say it... a really upside down image of Islam country. I know Sultan Al Fatih accomplished the Prophet vision to rule the world with Islam at Constantinople but I also aware how Kamal Antartuk destroy all of it. I don't expect much to see the Islam value in their drama as most of our drama also not representing the true Islam.
But it is kind of awkward to see someone that portrays as the hero, the good son of his parent, the protectors of his family and the man who stand for people justice to do improper act with a married woman. I am saying this because from the beginning everyone in his family is proud for him as the successful, full of dignity and values, with no flaws at all. His mother had once told him to protect their family dignity by stop the improper relationship with a married woman. But still, there are some scene that makes me wonder why anyone don't judge his wrongdoings and justifies it by saying it is an act of love. At first I really respect both Nihan and Kemal character, but eventually they are not as good as I thought. It is not really a pure love if you don't know to read between the lines.
Love is love but your responsibility in marriage is the first priority. Yes, your husband is cruel as syaitan nirojim but still you can't be a slut who give her virginity to someone other than your husband. Ok, it is a spoiler but Nihan and Kemal really had a child before they marriage to each other. There also a scene where they escape to some place like they are having a honeymoon.
I mean god grieve, girl! You are once be the girl who full of pride that stand for yourself in front of your cruel husband. But you destroy all that pride by giving up your dignity to your so called true lover. Love is love, but no need to go that far.
I bet many of conservative girl like me would feel cultural shock watching this drama. You said 'assalamualaikum' to each other, always say good words 'masyaallah' 'alhamdulillah' 'insyaallah'
'wallah wallah' even in bad time (seldomly curse) but still don't understand the real meaning of your religion that forbid alcohol, not covering aurah, zina and other thing. You caged your daughter from being too sociable but never say anything when she audition for a models wearing tight outfit. You are worrying about the neighbours talk when your daughter had a rush marriage but not aware of both of your son doing zina before marriage. You are potraying as a good man from the beginning (prefer marriage over dating) but make him a drunkard when hard time come (and people never question it).
I was mind blown by the cultural shock i found in this drama. Maybe because if mentioning about Istanbul, Malaysian people only know about Haye Sofya, Marmara tragedy, how Erdogan accept Rohingya people with open hand.... all the good stuff that represent Islam. But they don't really aware of what Kamal Antartuk done to that country that changes their people perception about the true Islam. All of the characters I believe is Islam but not practicing it.
Hmmm.. seem like someone feeling piss off. Of course I am. We in Malaysia also like that. Look at our movie and drama, is it representing Islam? I think both of the country is at the same level and situation but we much better in pretence.
Hahaha.
Sentap.
Ok, next drama 'I belonged to you' (made in China)
No comments:
Post a Comment